🔗 Share this article

Accepting the need for change

Ruben Amorim's preferred three-at-the-back system isn't the root cause of United's ongoing challenges. Old Trafford are recovering from prolonged organizational issues and the current squad is still developing, displaying quality in particular roles while glaring deficiencies remain elsewhere.

That said, systemic issues exist within the current tactical approach, most notably numerical disadvantages in the middle and width problems that demand solutions. Tacticians elsewhere have effectively handled comparable situations – Antonio Conte with Chelsea and the Austrian coach in South London demonstrate that player movement matters more than starting positions.

The manager recently commented: "Our formation isn't the issue, our performances are," comparable to focusing on effects rather than causes. Rival clubs have regularly exposed the same weaknesses in Amorim's approach for multiple months, not resulting from tactical ignorance but because the system itself includes structural weaknesses.

Consequently, supporters cannot anticipate a sudden breakthrough where all pieces connect, just as big-money transfers cannot single-handedly fix the core challenges. The London club's recent match functions as a perfect example – even after losing their manager and key players during the break, they adjusted their tactical setup deliberately to target Amorim's unchanged tactics.

When Erik ten Hag joined Manchester United, it was soon clear that Ajax's playing style didn't transfer to the English top flight; his refusal to modify proved decisive in his eventual departure. Presently United's coach – who appears to have the complete skill set for the game's most demanding role other than versatility – is mirroring similar errors and missing a golden opportunity. For the first time the club has proprietors dedicated to securing victories rather than financial gain.

Adjusting the outside centre-backs

Wide central defenders perform vital functions in the current setup: they advance with the ball, make important tackles, monitor spaces, alter attacking focus, initiate attacks and join offensive phases. Any observer might wonder whether utilizing a pair of such multi-functional defenders in a three-man defense makes sense when a back four could address midfield shortages.

Currently, these defensive players find themselves restricted by enemy strikers who, through simple positioning, prevent them from advancing into midfield as the system requires. This development enables teams with numerical superiority to circumvent the middle third, creating urgent problems that demand solutions.

Possible solutions include instructing centre-backs to advance regardless – though this risks defensive exposure – or dropping Matheus Cunha to facilitate possession, sacrificing attacking threat but exploiting his driving runs. The most sensible change involves modifying the defensive approach from the current aggressive setup to a more balanced 4-4-2 that provides better coverage and removes the requirement for defenders to advance.

Reintegrating Kobbie Mainoo

United's current tactical plan of chaotic direct football requires United to empty central areas and rely on long balls, banking on exceptional quality rather than systematic chance creation. Despite xG numbers show promise, match observations demonstrate that current chance creation result primarily from penalty awards and low-probability efforts rather than sustained pressure.

Elite clubs control matches through pace control. The team's incapacity to do this doesn't fall solely on Amorim's approach; reports indicate he requested central additions during the transfer period but encountered resistance from club executives. Regardless of blame, the existing condition cannot continue.

The regular central duo of the experienced midfielders, with Manuel Ugarte offering backup, has limited opportunities for the academy graduate. Despite valid reservations exist about his strength progression and progressive passing, marginalizing this ability raises questions about the system's effectiveness.

Casemiro, Fernandes and Ugarte embody rapid transitions, whereas the Englishman brings tempo control. During his Portuguese tenure, his squad could launch early attacks due to talent disparity against most Primeira Liga opponents, confident they would regain control if the attack broke down. However in the Premier League, the competitive level means sloppy ball circulation faces quick consequences, while physical dominance alone won't secure results.

The midfielder's technical ability stands out, and while partnering him with Fernandes creates defensive concerns, these weaknesses matter less in a controlling side. Given United's defensive record showing they concede more high-quality chances than all competitors, utilizing the academy product appears reasonable to try as other solutions have proven unsuccessful. While uncertainty remains about his specific function in the current setup, consistent minutes represents the optimal growth route and probably wouldn't damage existing circumstances.

Improving wing effectiveness

On United's right side, the partnership of the two attackers should theoretically work given their shared attributes of imagination, understanding and grit. When combined with the young French defender, they might create a productive relationship that improves creative output. Currently however, static movement makes opponents' jobs simpler for prepared opponents.

Amorim must implement structured rotation patterns that generate confusion through frequent role switching. Ball distribution must show diversity – not always to feet but frequently ahead of runners to optimize forward movement. This tactic enables inward movement, eliminating markers and opening channels for shots or crosses.

In left-wing areas, the full-back regularly gets opportunities in attacking zones even without the technical refinement to utilize productively. Adjusting his positioning slightly deeper would utilize his defensive ability and driving runs to {supply more creative players|service better attackers|provide for